The Great LEGO Debate: New vs. Second-Hand Sets

LEGO has been a beloved brand for decades, captivating the imaginations of both children and adults. Whether you're an AFOL (Adult Fan of LEGO) or a parent nurturing your child's creativity, the decision to buy LEGO sets often comes down to one key question: Should you buy them new or opt for second-hand sets? Both options have their pros and cons, and making the right choice depends on your priorities and circumstances.

The Case for Buying New LEGO Sets

Pristine Condition

When you buy a new LEGO set, you can expect it to be in mint condition. The pieces are shiny, the instructions are crisp, and the box is unmarred. For collectors or those giving a LEGO set as a gift, this untouched state is often a major selling point. There's something undeniably satisfying about breaking open a fresh set and being the first to assemble it.

Complete and Consistent

New sets come with the guarantee of completeness. Every piece should be present, and the colors will match perfectly since they're from the same production batch. This consistency is crucial if you're following the instructions closely or if you're a collector who values authenticity.

Access to the Latest Releases

If you're eager to get your hands on the latest LEGO set, buying new is the only way to go. Whether it's a highly anticipated themed set or a limited edition, purchasing new ensures that you’re part of the latest LEGO experience.

Support for the Brand

By buying new, you directly support LEGO, which in turn enables the company to continue producing innovative and exciting products. Plus, you get the benefit of customer support and warranties, something not guaranteed with second-hand purchases.

The Case for Buying Second-Hand LEGO Sets

Cost Savings

One of the biggest advantages of buying second-hand LEGO sets is the cost. New LEGO sets can be expensive, especially the larger and more intricate ones. Second-hand sets often come at a fraction of the price, making it easier to expand your collection or indulge in more elaborate builds without breaking the bank.

Sustainability

Buying second-hand is a more sustainable option. You're giving pre-loved LEGO a new lease on life, reducing the demand for new plastic production. In a world increasingly aware of environmental impact, choosing second-hand is a small but meaningful way to contribute to sustainability.

Rare and Retired Sets

Sometimes, the set you're after is no longer available new. In these cases, the second-hand market is the only option. Whether you're looking for a rare vintage set or a retired fan-favorite, buying used can be the key to unlocking a piece of LEGO history.

Potential for Bulk Purchases

Second-hand LEGO often comes in bulk, which can be a treasure trove for creative builders. You might not know exactly what you'll get, but the variety and quantity can fuel endless imaginative builds. This is particularly appealing if you're less concerned with following instructions and more interested in freeform building.

Considerations for Second-Hand LEGO Purchases

If you decide to go the second-hand route, there are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Condition: Inspect photos carefully or ask for more details about the set’s condition. Check for missing pieces, discolored bricks, or damaged instructions.

  • Seller Reputation: Whether you're buying from an individual or a marketplace, look for reviews or ratings. A reputable seller is more likely to be transparent about the set’s condition and completeness.

  • Price Comparison: Even in the second-hand market, prices can vary. Do a little research to ensure you're getting a fair deal, especially for rare or vintage sets.

  • Sanitization: Remember that second-hand LEGO has been pre-owned. While LEGO bricks are easy to clean, you'll want to sanitize them before handing them over to your kids or adding them to your collection.

The Best of Both Worlds?

Ultimately, whether you choose to buy new or second-hand LEGO sets comes down to what matters most to you. If you’re after the latest releases, a guarantee of completeness, and pristine condition, buying new is likely the better option. However, if you’re looking to save money, reduce environmental impact, or find a rare gem, the second-hand market offers plenty of opportunities.

In the end, there’s no right or wrong choice—just the one that best suits your needs. And who knows? You might find yourself mixing both new and second-hand LEGO sets to create a collection that’s uniquely yours. Happy building!

Live that Brick Life!

BrickLifer

BrickLifer is an official affiliate of the LEGO® group.

BrickLifer

Husband to an amazing woman, who keeps me alive. Father of 2 rambunctious and just trying to have fun in this crazy life.

https://www.bricklifer.com
Previous
Previous

Building the Perfect LEGO City: A Dream for Every AFOL

Next
Next

The Time Commitment of AFOLs: How Long Does It Take to Build a LEGO Set?